The American Conservative Jewish movement, traditionally characterized by its adherence to Halakha (Jewish law) while embracing modern scholarship, has faced significant internal debate regarding the inclusion of homosexual individuals. This article explores the evolving landscape of this discussion, examining the historical context, the theological and halakhic arguments, and the pragmatic efforts undertaken by various stakeholders to foster greater inclusivity. Drawing upon sociological and theological perspectives, we analyze the challenges and opportunities inherent in this process, highlighting the role of activism, narrative, and evolving understandings of identity within a religious framework. The article argues that while significant hurdles remain, a "stream in the desert" is indeed emerging, indicating a growing movement towards embracing homosexual Jews within the Conservative movement.

American Conservative Judaism, homosexual inclusion, LGBTQ+ acceptance, religious inclusion, faith and sexuality, Jewish communities, sexual minority rights

1. Acconcia, Giuseppe, Aurora Perego, and Lorenza Perini. 2024. LGBTQ activism in repressive contexts: The struggle for (in)visibility in Egypt, Tunisia and Turkey. Social Movement Studies 23: 207–25.

2. Almog, Shulamit. 2009. Trauma, Narrative and Law. In Dalia Dorner Book 143. Available online: https://ssrn.com/abstract=2526196 (accessed on 25 April 2025).

3. Asal Victor, Amanda Murdie, and Udi Sommer. 2017. Rainbows for rights: The role of LGBT activism in gay rights promotion. Societies Without Borders 12: 13.

4. Avishai, Orit. 2023. Queer Judaism: LGBT Activism and the Remaking of Jewish Orthodoxy in Israel. New York: NYU Press.

5. Baum, Howell S. 2001. How should we evaluate community initiatives? Journal of the American Planning Association 67: 147–58.

6. Ben-Lulu, Elazar. 2024. ‘Apples–out, mushrooms–in’; toward a theology of queer advocacy in the American Jewish community. Practical Theology 17: 162–79.

7. Ben-Lulu, Elazar. 2023. Empathy from the margins: Observing Beta Israel (Ethiopian Jews) events in a reform Jewish congregation. Religions 14: 324.

8. Ben-Lulu, Elazar. 2022. Who has the right to the city? Reform Jewish rituals of gender-religious resistance in Tel Aviv-Jaffa. Gender, Place & Culture 29: 1251–73.

9. Bobo, Kim, Jackie Kendall, and Steve Max. 2001. Organizing for Social Change: Midwest Academy Manual for Activists. Santa Ana: Seven Locks Press.

10. Butler, Judith. 1995. Melancholy gender—Refused identification. Psychoanalytic Dialogues 5: 165–80.

11. Chen, Sally Xiaojin. 2020. Relational interaction and embodiment: Conceptualizing meanings of LGBTQ+ activism in digital China. Communication and the Public 5: 134–48.

12. Cherry, Shai. 2012. Ethical Theories in the Conservative Movement. In The Oxford Handbook of Jewish Ethics and Morality. Edited by Elliot N. Dorff and Jonathan K. Crane. Oxford: Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780199736065.013.0014.

13. Cohen, Michael R. 2012. The Birth of Conservative Judaism: Solomon Schechter’s Disciples and the Creation of an American Religious Movement. New York: Columbia University Press.

14. Coyle, Adrian, and Deborah Rafalin. 2001. Jewish gay men’s accounts of negotiating cultural, religious, and sexual identity: A qualitative study. Journal of Psychology & Human Sexuality 12: 21–48.

15. DeLuca, Kevin Michael. 1999. The possibilities of nature in a postmodern age: The rhetorical tactics of environmental justice groups. Communication Theory 9: 189–215.

16. Diament, Sara. 2007. An introduction to sexuality education for Orthodox Jewish female high school students. American Journal of Sexuality Education 2: 79–90.

17. Drinkwater, Gregg. 2020. Building Queer Judaism: Gay Synagogues and the Transformation of an American Religious Community, 1948–1990. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Colorado at Boulder, Boulder, CO, USA.

18. Droff, Elliot. 1992. Jewish Norms for Sexual Behavior: A Responsum Embodying a Proposal (March 25, 1992), in RESPONSA OF THE CJLS 1991–2000, 691–711. Available online: https://www.rabbinicalassembly.org/sites/default/files/public/halakhah/teshuvot/19912000/dorff_homosexuality.pdf (accessed on 25 April 2025).

19. Dupree, Amber Erin. 2018. Reevaluating Religion: A Case for Inclusivity of LGBTQ Christians in the Church. Honors Theses. 1257. Available online: https://egrove.olemiss.edu/hon_thesis/1257 (accessed on 25 April 2025).

20. Grant, Lisa, and Michal Muszkat-Barkan. 2011. Rabbis as educators: Their professional training and identity formation. In International Handbook of Jewish Education. Dordrecht: Springer, pp. 1001–20.

21. Hartal, Gilly. 2020. Israel’s LGBT movement and interest groups. In Oxford Research Encyclopedia of Politics. Available online: https://oxfordre.com/politics/view/10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.001.0001/acrefore-9780190228637-e-1295 (accessed on 25 April 2025).

22. Hogeterp, Mike. 2020. A Theology of Advocacy—Musings of a Practitioner: Do Justic. Available online: https://dojustice.crcna.org/article/theology-advocacy-musings-practitioner (accessed on 25 April 2025).

23. Irshai, Ronit. 2019. The construction of gender in halakhic Responsa by the Reform movement: Transgender people as a case study. Journal of Modern Jewish Studies 18: 160–76.

24. Job, Sarah A., Andrea R. Kaniuka, Emerson A. Todd, Brittney Storey, and Byron D. Brooks. 2023. Pride and Protests: A Mixed-Methods Examination of LGBTQ + Activism and Well-Being. Sexual and Gender Diversity in Social Services 36: 273–304. https://doi.org/10.1080/10538720.2023.2252756.

25. Kupper, Yoni., and Danny. Kaplan. 2010. When the private meets the public: The politics of recognition in an LGBT organization for education and social change. Israeli Sociology 12: 159–80.

26. Lea Gaydos, H. 2005. Understanding personal narratives: An approach to practice. Journal of Advanced Nursing 49: 254–59.

27. Libel-Hass, Einat, and Adam S. Ferziger. 2022. A Synagogue Center Grows in Tel Aviv: On Glocalization, Consumerism and Religion. Modern Judaism 42: 273–304.

28. Maier, Jessie. 2022. Queering Eve: Imagining Transgender Acceptance in Orthodox Judaism. Women in Judaism: A Multidisciplinary e‐Journal 19: 1–17.

29. Riessman, Catherine Kohler. 2003. Analysis of personal narratives. In Inside Interviewing: New Lenses, New Concerns. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage, pp. 331–46.

30. Roberts-DeGennaro, Maria. 2011. Planned change efforts in organizations and communities: Evidence-informed practice. In Using Evidence to Inform Practice for Community and Organizational Change. Edited by Maria Roberts-DeGennaro and Sondra J. Fogel. Chicago: Lyceum, pp. 5–14.

31. Rodriguez, Eric M., and Suzanne C. Ouellette. 2000. Gay and lesbian Christians: Homosexual and religious identity integration in the members and participants of a gay-positive church. Journal for the Scientific Study of Religion 39: 333–47.

32. Roth, Joel. 2002. Homosexuality. Responsa: 1991–2000. Edited by K. Abelson and D. J. Fine. New York: The Rabbinical Assembly, pp. 613–90.

33. Santiago, Anna Maria, Tracy M. Soska, and Lorraine M. Gutierrez. 2017. Improving the effectiveness of community-based interventions: Recent lessons from community practice. Journal of Community Practice 25: 139–42.

34. Schnoor, Randal F. 2006. Being gay and Jewish: Negotiating intersecting identities. Sociology of Religion 67: 43–60.

35. Shapiro, Edward. 2013. The crisis of conservative Judaism. First Things 233, 27–31.

36. Shragge, Eric. 2013. Activism and Social Change: Lessons for Community Organizing. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

37. Silverstein, Alan. 2001. Modernists vs. Traditionalists: Competition and Legitimacy within American Conservative Judaism. In Studies in Contemporary Jewry: Volume XVII: Who owns Judaism? Public Religion and Private Faith in America and Israel. Oxford: Oxford University Press, pp. 34–55.

38. Stivers, Camilla. 1993. Reflections on the role of personal narrative in social science. Journal of Women in Culture and Society 18: 408–25.

39. Strassfeld, Max K. 2022. Trans Talmud: Androgynes and Eunuchs in Rabbinic Literature. Berkeley: University of California Press.

40. Thumma, Scott. 1991. Negotiating a religious identity: The case of the gay evangelical. Sociological analysis 52: 333–47.

41. Waxman, Mordecai. 1958. Tradition and Change: The Development of Conservative Judaism. New York: Jewish Theological Seminary of America.

42. Wertheimer, Jack, ed. 2007. Family Matters: Jewish Education in an Age of Choice. Waltham, MA: Brandeis University Press.

43. Wertheimer, Jack. 2018. The New American Judaism: How Jews Practice Their Religion Today. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

44. Westoby, Peter, and Gerard Dowling. 2013. Theory and Practice of Dialogical Community Development: International Perspectives. London: Routledge.

45. Woodford, Michael R., Brittanie Atteberry,Matthew Derr and Michael Howell. 2013. Endorsement for civil rights for lesbian, gay, bisexual, and transgender people among heterosexual college students: Informing socially just policy advocacy. Journal of Community Practice 21: 203–27.

46. Yuter, Joshua. 2008. Conservative Judaism and Homosexuality: Understanding the New Debate. A paper submitted for the Master of Arts degree in the Master of Arts Program in the Social Sciences. Chicago: The University of Chicago.

47. Ben-Lulu, Elazar. 2025. Doorposts of Inclusion: Trans Pride Mezuzah as a Marker of Jewish-Queer Space. Material Religion 1–27.

48. Ben-Lulu, Elazar. 2021. Performing Gender and Political Recognition: Israeli Reform Jewish Life-cycle Rituals. Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 50: 202–30.

49. Bernstein, Mary. 2005. Identity politics. Annual Review of Sociology 31: 47–74.